Opinion - Letters to the Editor   

Unconvincing

This refers to the article "Eviscerating a holy cow" (Open Page, May 7). IITs are the benchmark for high-quality technological education. Therefore, the argument that the author — himself a student of IIT — is developing into a `techno-clerk' fails to convince. How does he explain the brand name created by the alumni of the institute? The atmosphere in IITs is what gives the IITians their tag. Students going into them should be worthy of it. Which is why the stress is on merit as the sole criterion for admission. Finally, one cannot expect everything to be taught in classrooms. It is surprising that the author feels his intellectual horizon has been restricted.

M.V. Srisha Rao,
Udyogamandal, Kerala

The article reflects a remarkable concern for social equity though it overshadows the analysis of the reservation issue. If, as the author says, grinding (coaching) is the only thing that has churned out success in the IITs, albeit at a cost, why does he not develop the argument to provide that facility to the deprived class? One must think of plans to support the backward sections up to a point instead of providing arbitrary reservation.

R. Agastya,
Hyderabad

The author deserves praise for his openness. A student of IIT speaking about IITs is indeed significant. The mention about reservation in the army is uncalled for, though the spirit behind the comparison is noteworthy.

U. Muralikrishna,
Visakhapatnam, A.P.

Printer friendly page  
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Stories in this Section

U.S. joins India's Moon mission
In the grip of a heatwave
Employment guarantee — signs of transformation
Blairism's failure: private delivery of public goods
Corrections and Clarifications
Justice for Dalits still a dream
BBC's coverage comes under fire
Different depictions of Robert Mugabe
Unconcerned move
Exit poll
Undernourished society
Unconvincing

Copyright © 2006, The Hindu. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu